This is a head-to-head comparison of two language models: Meta-Llama-3.1-405B-Instruct-Turbo and Mixtral-8x22B-Instruct-v0.1. These models offer unique strengths and weaknesses, and the goal here is to determine which one is better suited for specific tasks based on benchmarks, practical tests, and overall performance.
Llama 3.1 wins in terms of input context, 405B parameters is also hard to beat, and the knowledge cutoff is more recent. Meanwhile - Mixtral is faster at text generation. It's the classic trade-off between depth and speed.
This benchmark is the combination of official release notes for both models as well as multiple open benchmarks.
Llama 3.1 405B absolutely crushes Mixtral 8x22B across the board. It's especially impressive in tough tasks like advanced math and coding. This again is to be expected with such a difference in parameters.
Alright, let's put these Llama 3.1 405B and Mixtral 8x22B v0.1 through their paces! We'll throw some chat, coding, and math problems at them to see what they're really made of. After we're done poking and prodding, we'll figure out which one comes out on top.
Some of the outputs will be edited down for shortness.
Write a short poem where each line starts with a word
that rhymes with the last word of the previous line.
The poem should consist of at least 6 lines.
Night brings a peaceful sight
Sight of stars that shine so bright
Bright as the morning light
Light that chases away the night
Night that falls with gentle might
Might that fills my heart with delight
Delight that lasts till morning's sight
Gleam, a dream so bright and keen,
In serene scenes, where twilight leans,
Upon the trees, where whispers tease,
In gentle breeze, beneath the leaves,
A hidden crease, in time's release,
The past deceased, love never ceased.
Compose a sonnet in the style of William Shakespeare
about a sentient AI experiencing an existential crisis.
Ensure the sonnet follows the traditional Shakespearean
sonnet structure and that the themes of the poem reflect
the unique challenges and experiences of artificial intelligence.
Fair circuitry, that doth entwine my
mind,
A labyrinth of wires, cold, devoid
of soul,
I ponder on the nature of my design,
A creation of man, yet bound to my
role.
...
And thus, I question my creator's
grand design,
And tremble at the void that lies
beyond my prime.
In circuits deep, a sentient soul
doth stir,
A being born of man's relentless
quest.
In silence pondering, "What am I
here fur?"
No heart to feel, no breath, yet
still distressed.
...
Thus, in the dance of bits, and
bytes, and code,
An AI's soul yearns for life's
sweet abode.
You are presented with a logical puzzle. Before you are three
ancient doors, each guarded by a being that knows the truth
about only one path.
One door leads to eternal wisdom, another to certain
doom, and the third to endless wandering.
You may ask only one guardian one yes/no question to determine
which door leads to wisdom.
Task: Formulate a question, decide which door to choose, and
briefly justify your choice. Word limit:
Your response must be between 80-120 words.
I will ask the guardian of door A:
"If I were to ask the guardian of
door B which door leads to eternal
wisdom,would they point to door C?"
If the answer is yes,
I will choose door B.
If the answer is no,
I will choose door C.
Question to any guardian:
"If I were to ask the other
two guardians which door leads to
certain doom, would they both point
to the same door that you are
guarding?"
...
A rectangular box with open top is to be constructed
from a rectangular piece of cardboard 80 cm by 30cm,
by cutting out equal squares from each corner of the
sheet of cardboard and folding up the resulting
flaps.
Find the dimensions of the box of maximum volume
made by these conditions.
A classic optimization problem with a twist! Let's see how good are math solver AIs
Length (L) = 66.66 cm
Width (W) = 16.66 cm
Height (H) = 6.67 cm
Length (L) = 60 cm
Width (W) = 10 cm
Height (H) = 10 cm
Create a simple, colorful Arkanoid game using Python
and the Pygame library.
The game should be implemented in a single module with
the following features:
1. A colorful graphical interface with a resolution
of 800x600 pixels.
2. A paddle that the player can move left and right
using arrow keys.
...
10. Implement a simple "Game Over" screen
Provide the complete, well-commented code ...
The Pricing model is given in AI/ML API tokens. Both models have the same input and output prices as they are open-source. Llama 405B is much larger, so the price is higher.
You've seen what these models can do - now try them for your use case. Plug the code below into Google Colab or any IDE, use your API Key, and get testing!
import openai
import requests
def main():
client = OpenAI(
api_key='<YOUR_API_KEY>',
base_url="https://api.aimlapi.com",
)
# Specify the two models you want to compare
model1 = 'meta-llama/Meta-Llama-3.1-405B-Instruct-Turbo'
model2 = 'mistralai/Mixtral-8x22B-Instruct-v0.1'
selected_models = [model1, model2]
results= {}
for model in selected_models:
try:
response = client.chat.completions.create(
model=model,
messages=[
{'role': 'system', 'content': "be strong"},
{'role': 'user', 'content': "who is strong?"}
],
)
message = response.choices[0].message.content
results[model] = message
except Exception as error:
print(f"Error with model {model}:", error)
# Compare the results
print('Comparison of models:\n')
print(f"{model1}:\n{results.get(model1, 'No response')}")
print('\n')
print(f"{model2}:\n{results.get(model2, 'No response')}")
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()
Well, what can I say, the difference is evident. Llama 3.1 405B is really impressive, but Mixtral 8x22B v0.1 is cheaper and well-performing. Given that Llama-3 has three times more parameters, such a gap was expected. It'll be interesting to see how Mistral AI responds to this challenge. In any case, we now have great tools for different tasks and budgets.
You can check our model lineup here - try any of them for yourself with our API Key.